Without Comment, Judge Dismisses Girl Scout Cookie Lawsuit

CLAYTON, Mo. (KMOX) –  Without comment, without explanation — a St. Louis County circuit judge has dismissed a lawsuit brought by two teenaged sisters who were told they couldn’t sell Girl Scout cookies outside their Hazelwood home.

“We’re perplexed,” said Dave Roland, attorney for 16-year-old Caitlin Mills and her 14-year-old sister Abigail.

He says the ruling was handed down Friday by Circuit Judge Maura McShane, but his office only learned of it Tuesday.

“Hazelwood’s attorneys are telling the girls to seek a license that explicitly prohibits the sale of commodities,” Roland said.  “Even if they wanted the license it would be futile for them to apply for it.  All this fuss is about whether kids can sell cookies in their own front yard!”

Roland said he’ll seek a clarification from Judge McShane, but regardless of what he learns he says the case is not over.

He can file a motion for rehearing or simply start from scratch and refile the case in St. Louis County Circuit Court.



Copyright KMOX Radio

  • http://www.mofreedom.org/2011/08/st-louis-judge-delays-cookie-stand-challenge/ St. Louis Judge Delays Cookie Stand Challenge

    […] also think it would be worth reading Brett Blume’s short write-up on KMOX’s website. Tweet Filed Under: Press Releases, Property […]

  • baichide66

    The product or service was sent and recieved really swiftly outstanding support.

  • http://stlouis.cbslocal.com/2012/03/12/update-judge-agrees-to-hear-girl-scout-cookie-case/ UPDATE: Judge Agrees to Hear Girl Scout Cookie Case « CBS St. Louis

    […] Articles: Thin Mints and the Constitution — Two Girl Scouts Ask Court to Take Up Their Case Without Comment, Judge Dismisses Girl Scout Cookie Lawsuit Hazelwood Crackdown on Girl Scout […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Now
Thanksgiving Guide
Make Your Picks!

Listen Live