Cancer Study Suggests Lumpectomies May Be More Effective Than Mastectomies

ST. LOUIS (KMOX) – The latest evidence suggests less may be more when it comes to treating certain types of breast cancer.

A new study finds women with early stage breast cancer who had a lumpectomy and radiation actually had a better survival rate than those who underwent a mastectomy.

“There are lots of women who think the more [treatment] they do, the better they will do,” said researcher Dr. Shelley Hwang, chief of breast surgery at Duke Cancer Institute. “This refutes that.”

But a breast cancer surgeon at St. Louis University Cancer Center, Dr. Teresa Schwartz, says this was just an observational study and she would not feel comfortable telling her patients that a lumpectomy is the better way to go.

“I would definitely not tell a patient that, based on this one observational study, that having a lumpectomy is superior to having a mastectomy,” she said. “I do not have the literature to back that.”

“It is still a completely individualized decision that has a lot of patient-related factors and a lot of pathological-related factors that come into the decision-making process. This paper doesn’t clear all of that up.”

Women 50 and older saw the greatest benefit in this study: they were 13 percent less likely to die from breast cancer when they had the less radical surgery.


More From CBS St. Louis

KMOX Podcasts
As Heard On KMOX

Listen Live