ST. LOUIS–(KMOX)–A high stakes case for developer Paul McKee, as his attorney calls on a state appeals court to restore a major tax break for McKee’s stalled northside redevelopment plan.

McKee sat watching in a dark pin stripe suit, as attorney Paul Puricelli argued before the three judge panel for restoration of the $390 million tax increment finance package nullified in July 2010 by Judge Robert Dierker.

“This case questions whether the TIF act can be used to subsidize large scale redvelopment projects that will evolve over time with changing markets, politics and technology,” Puricelli said.

Puricelli was seeking to deal with the finding by Judge Dierker that McKee’s plan “lacked a specific project” to qualify under current TIF law.  Puricelli argued that unlike a smaller project such as a “Walmart on a corner,” McKee’s ambitions $8 billion, 23 year plan needs some open-endedness to adapt and evolve.

Puricelli also noted that McKee has invested “millions” of his own money in the plan and is committed to making it work.

img 3301 Paul McKee Fights to Get His TIF Back for Northside Redevelopment Project

Attorney Bevis Schock

An attorney representing plaintiff’s against McKee, Bevis Schock, argued that the court should not “shed a tear for Paul McKee.”

“The sympathy vote goes for the homeowner,” Schock said, “the lady whose house was blighted, whose value went down and who doesn’t know whether she’s going to be able to live in the house.”

Puricelli fired back that McKee has no plans for eminent domain, and if some isolated homes do need to be knocked down, that would require the approval of the St. Louis Board of Aldermen.

Lawyers against McKee also sought to raise doubts about his financial ability to pull off the plan. Schock told judges that McKee’s revenue projections are “from another universe,” that property values in north St. Louis would have to soar to “Ladue like” values to make his numbers work.

Another lawyer for the plaintiffs, D.B. Amon, also questioned McKee’s bankability.

“The proponents of the plan, Paul McKee and others, are financially strapped,” Amon said after the hearing, “He just lost a federal lawsuit with Bank South for $34 million dollars, which he’s personally on the hook for.”

img 3300 Paul McKee Fights to Get His TIF Back for Northside Redevelopment Project

Attorney D.B. Amon


McKee’s attorney, Paul Puricelli, argues that McKee is “very bankable,” and expects to win an appeal in the Bank South case.

McKee’s side pointed out afterwards that attorneys for the plaintiffs spent part of their clients’ valuable time before the panel arguing that they should be allowed to get their legal fees.

In the hallway after the hearing, McKee declined to talk about the case pending the appeals court decision.

When asked if he would still press forward with the northside plan — if he loses this case — McKee says he would “go back and start over.”

When asked if he would give up, McKee said, “No, never.”

A ruling in the case could take months.

Copyright KMOX

Comments (3)
  1. ben says:

    So let me get this straight – someone is arguing, with a straight face, that because the specific details of a 23-year plan cannot be fully articulated, that it is more economically viable to let the zone around the Pruitt-Igoe-Void (PIV for future reference) rot for even longer than it already has, than to…I don’t know…actually do something with vision? ROFL!

  2. ben says:

    To follow up on my previous comment: THAT ARGUMENT IS BEING MADE WITH A STRAIGHT FACE!!??!??!??!? :0

  3. stlmom4 says:

    It’s criminal that McKee has acquired that land and buildings while letting them rot and leaving the residents with no way to better their neighborhood despite many who tried to buy properties over the years. TIF? NO! He has taken away so many rights from the property owners and residents of the near north side. SHAME!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

More From CBS St. Louis

Download The App

Listen Live