Commission Approves Tear-Down of Pevely Dairy Buildings

Michael Calhoun

ST. LOUIS (KMOX) – The old Pevely Dairy smokestack, sign and buildings are toast.

The city’s planning commission voted Wednesday night, with one exception, to overturn an earlier ruling from the preservation Board and allow Saint Louis University to demolish the entire Pevely complex.

In its place will be a $75 million dollars outpatient addition to the SLU hospital complex.

“I think I’m happy,” said SLU’s President, Father Lawrence Biondi, after the meeting’s conclusion. He hopes to have shovels in the ground for the four-to-six story building by this fall.

Commissioners voiced their votes in his favor just minutes after he raised his hand from the audience, stood, and said:

“What I forsee, if you don’t approve our request, is that we would have to shut down our medical school and find property in west county,” noting that 35 years ago, Maryville offered up land for the university to move west. Earlier, Biondi cited the school’s record of renovating and restoring historic buildings and also highlighted the law school’s impending move to downtown.

After the meeting, KMOX asked Biondi about the threat.

“This is now approved, so that point is moot,” he said.

Preservation board members had previously okayed the demolition of two support buildings, but denied demolition permits for the smokestack and main office building. Wednesday’s decision allows the smokestack and office to be torn down once SLU obtains a building permit for the new health center building.

There is no appeal process.

Steve Patterson, blogger at UrbanReviewSTL.com and preservation advocate, was at the meeting and, afterwards, expressed his disappointment that a building on the National Register of Historic Places was so easily sentenced to the scrap heap.pevely rendering Commission Approves Tear Down of Pevely Dairy Buildings

He and others are also upset with designs for the new “ambulatory care center,” which show the building set far back from the street, behind a grassy lawn and fountain.

“Not everyone wants suburbia. We don’t want to see green grass everywhere,” Patterson lamented. The end of Pevely, he said, removes the last urban element at the intersection of Chouteau and Grand. Caddy-corner to the site is a fast food restaurant.

A vacant lot across the street is owned by SLU and preservationists question why the center couldn’t be built there.

“You have physicians that practice at the hospital that’ll be occupying this ambulatory care center,” said architect Steve Smith. “They can’t be crossing Chouteau. We don’t want them hopping in their car and driving. This is intended to be a walkable campus.”

Smith, President and CEO of the Lawrence Group, stressed that possible alternatives for reuse of the Pevely office building had been exhausted. The floorplans for the health center are incompatible with the structure and, he said, there is no interest from private developers.

He also said that the new building’s plans are fluid.

“I think it could look different. I think we’ll take a fresh look at the design for the building.”

One certain change is the smokestack. It’s still standing in the current proposal, but SLU was granted the right to tear it down after arguing that it would take $500,000 to simply keep it from falling down and much more to make it earthquake-resistant.

KMOX © Copyright 2011 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Comments

One Comment

  1. Susan says:

    I’m very disappointed in this decision. SLU lacks imagination and respect for the urban area in which their university is located. This is not good for the city. I have a pretty low opinion of architects who cannot build or figure out how to retrofit an area that already has large, functioning buildings. Shame on you for tearing down historic buildings and affirming the decisions of a university that cares very little about the city. What is the point of a National Historic registry when myopic (and probably highly influenced) individuals on a local committee can so easily overturn things and have buildings razed?

  2. Terry Meyer says:

    I am happy to see that the City of St. Louis finally can see the big picture “The huge amount of money that SLU pumps into this community pays salaries, generates tax income, and improves the community” Now how would an old dairy do that if the University decided to take its campus to St. Louis County?.

    Again we need to stop dwelling in the past we have enough history and start looking towards the future. This is just one of the reasons that this city is in the condition that it is in”On Life Support”

    Contratulations St. Louis University!

    1. Rob says:

      So, you would prefer that all old historic buildings get torn down & replaced with glass & steel? Sad that you have no respect for the past.

  3. Ed Golterman says:

    This is fine, now Mr. Slayo fill in the lost tax revenue as the central corridor from Washington University and the Park to Cortex to SLU is tax- sheltered. You have to create for-profit businesses right now. Francis-do you hear me? Or go after money the not-for-profits rake in in their profit centers-entertainment, special events, parties, etc. Or revoke the not-for profit privilidege.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More From CBS St. Louis

Live Inspired
Photography In A Flash

Listen Live